Gavin Newsom sued by prosecutors and victim rights group to bar mass death row commutation
on November 17, 2026
By using our sites, you agree to Our Privacy Policy and performance cookies.
on November 17, 2026
Gov. Gavin Newsom
California Governor Gavin Newsom is facing a lawsuit from prosecutors and victims' rights groups who argue that his decision to commute the death sentences of over 500 inmates disregards legal procedures and constitutional safeguards. The plaintiffs claim he overstepped his authority by not providing individualized reviews or notifying victims' families before making this decision.
The plaintiffs in the lawsuit challenging Gavin Newsom’s planned death-row commutations include the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, 30 county district attorneys, and more than two dozen victims’ family members. They argue that the plan lacked required notice and individual review.These claims highlight concerns about the potential overreach of executive power and the need to uphold constitutional safeguards in the clemency process.
The plaintiffs, which include the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation and various district attorneys, argue that:
Overstepping Authority: Newsom's clemency power does not allow for mass commutations that ignore constitutional safeguards.
Lack of Individual Reviews: The lawsuit contends that Newsom failed to conduct individualized reviews of each case, which is a required legal procedure.
Failure to Notify Victims: The plaintiffs assert that victims' families were not properly notified, denying them the opportunity to voice their opinions before the commutation decisions were made.
Associations representing district attorneys, police officers and crime survivors said in the lawsuit that California law does not allow a blanket commutation like the one Mr. Newsom is seeking. They say that one person does not have the power to overrule the judgment of thousands of jurors and hundreds of judges in one fell swoop.
“A mass clemency is inconsistent with a scheme designed to create a public process that ensures that all relevant information is considered regarding the individual crime and criminal,” the lawsuit says.
Other lawyers have argued that the governor has broad authority to grant clemency and that he may empty death row based on his moral opposition to capital punishment, regardless of the details of each case.
Legal Implications
The lawsuit expresses the importance of adhering to legal procedures and protecting the rights of victims. It seeks to ensure that no governor can act above the law, reinforcing the need for accountability in the exercise of executive power. The court has asked that opinions about Mr. Newsom’s commutation request be filed by Nov. 24. It must make a decision before he leaves office on Jan. 4.
Victim's Families
Victim's family members emphasized deep anguish at the notion that their loved ones’ killers could receive mercy. The relatives blasted Mr. Newsom for disrespecting them and said his actions had opened up old wounds, causing them to lose faith in the finality they had sought from the justice system.
Background on Newsom's Decision
On November 5, 2026, Newsom announced his intention to commute the sentences of 548 death row inmates, citing moral objections to state-sanctioned killing. This decision has sparked significant controversy, as California has not executed anyone since 2006, and the state has a moratorium on executions established by Newsom himself in 2019.
Surviving family members of murder victims held dueling news conferences last week over Mr. Newsom’s commutations. The members stated that it supported his decision and urged the court to move swiftly to approve commutations. The relatives said that executions would not help them heal from their losses and said they would rather see the justice system deliver more support for survivors of violence.